In a report entitled “The History of a Lawsuit in the Republic of Ecuador”, dedicated to the House of Commons of Great Britain and Ireland, a British gentleman narrated his experience in Ecuador after filing a lawsuit in 1860. He affirmed that “an ordinary suit baffles all calculation, and not unfrequently exceeds the natural term of a man’s life” and that “the corrupt administration of justice is proverbial”. Unfortunately, despite that more than 150 years have passed, these criticisms are still heard today.
The Chevron Saga is acquainted with the above accusations and certainly represents some of the most notorious and important cases that the world has witnessed. These involve litigations in multiple jurisdictions, investment arbitrations (Chevron I and Chevron II) and an Inter-State arbitration between Ecuador and the United States of America. From domestic law to international law of foreign investment, the courts and arbitral tribunals involved have addressed several legal issues and almost all the possible complexities that adjudicative proceedings could see. Similarly, its protagonists include indigenous people, states, professionals, aliens (i.e. foreign investors), and even a ghost(writer). Additionally, some of them have worn different hats in diverse but related proceedings, sometimes as plaintiffs, defendants, or as third parties.
Today, the Constitutional Court of Ecuador is the principal character. As the highest body of constitutional control, interpretation and administration of justice in Ecuador, the Constitutional Court must render a critical judgment. This sentence will give rise to a new chapter in the ongoing international proceedings and will certainly have a significant influence in the allegations of denial of justice made against Ecuador in Chevron II. The question that arises, however, is whether the Court’s ruling would either represent Ecuador’s redemption or the final configuration of its international responsibility.
Remember, Remember the Third of November
Forum non conveniens, environmental damages and fraud. These issues could broadly summarize the main discussions that originated and that subsequently were litigated before the Ecuadorian courts and abroad. On November 3, 1993, the class action lawsuit that started the Chevron Saga was filed in the United States District Court For the Southern District of New York (the Aguinda Litigation). The plaintiffs sought compensation for damages, yet the case was dismissed on forum non conveniens grounds. In 2002, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals confirmed the decision to dismiss the litigation and, in 2003, Chevron was sued in Lago Agrio, Ecuador (the Lago Agrio Litigation).
The first instance judgment was issued on February 14, 2011, ordering Chevron to pay more than US$18.2 billion, including punitive damages (the Lago Agrio Judgment). On January 3, 2012, the appellate court affirmed the Lago Agrio Judgment. Later, Chevron filed a cassation recourse on January 20, 2012, and in November 12, 2013, the National Court of Ecuador revoked the punitive damages granted as these are not recognized by Ecuadorian law, though it ratified the rest of the inferior judgments.
Consequently, Chevron filed an Extraordinary Action of Protection (EAP) on December 23, 2013. Under this special constitutional action, a person can challenge judgments in which there have been violations of constitutional rights and, therefore, allows the Constitutional Court to review such judgments on points of constitutional law. Chevron argued that the National Court, through its judgment, violated several constitutional rights (namely, due process rights, legal certainty, the right to defense, to submit and challenge evidence, proportionality, and others).
Accordingly, Chevron asked the Constitutional Court: (i) to declare that the cassation judgment has violated its constitutional rights; (ii) to order the integral reparation of its rights, which would imply that the cassation judgment would be left with no effect; and, (iii) to reverse the process to the moment when the earliest violation of Chevron’s constitutional rights took place.
On March 20, 2014, the EAP was admitted and on October 1st, 2015, the Constitutional Judge assigned to write the draft judgment sent it to the Plenary of the Court for its approval. Ecuadorian law establishes that the Court should issue its judgment within 30 days of receiving the EAP file, nevertheless the Court has interpreted this to mean that this period is counted from when the draft judgment has been included in the Plenary’s agenda, which has not happened yet. The content of the draft is confidential, yet once approved it will be public and not subject to any appeal whatsoever.
Denial of Justice
Whilst the Lago Agrio Litigation was in process, Chevron Corporation and Texaco Petroleum Corporation (Chevron and Texaco) started two investment arbitrations against Ecuador. The former is concluded and the latter is still pending. In Chevron I, the Arbitral Tribunal found that Ecuador breached the Ecuador-United States Bilateral Investment Treaty (Ecuador-US BIT). Specifically, the Tribunal established in its final award that Ecuador breached Article II(7) of the Ecuador-US BIT through the undue delay of its courts and held it was liable for damages for more than US$96 million.
On the other hand, in Chevron II, Chevron and Texaco requested the Tribunal to declare, inter alia, that Ecuador breached the Ecuador-US BIT, including its obligations to afford fair and equitable treatment, full protection and security, effective means of enforcing rights, non-arbitrary treatment, non-discriminatory treatment, and to observe obligations it entered into under investment agreements. Afterwards, in a Supplemental Memorial on the Merits, Chevron and Texaco added a claim for denial of justice under customary international law.
Likewise, in 2011, Chevron brought an action under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act against, amongst others, Steven Donziger, the plaintiff’s counsel in the Lago Agrio Litigation. Chevron asserted that the Lago Agrio Judgment was procured by fraud and sought to prevent any of them from profiting from the alleged fraud or from seeking to enforce the Judgment in the United States. On March 4, 2014, District Judge Lewis Kaplan concluded that the Judgment was obtained by corrupt means and prevented the defendants from benefitting from it in any way. Then, on August 8, 2016, the Second Circuit affirmed Judge Kaplan’s judgment, but did not invalidate the Lago Agrio Judgment.
On August 26, 2016, Chevron II’s Tribunal, in its Procedural Order No. 45, admitted the judgment of the Second Circuit to the arbitration proceedings, confirmed that the evidence adduced before the District Court would be treated as evidence in the arbitration, and requested the parties to submit a copy of an amicus brief submitted by Ecuador in the Second Circuit proceedings.
Similarly, the Constitutional Court’s ruling is undoubtedly going to be a fundamental piece in the denial of justice claim pursued in Chevron II. Ecuador maintains that Chevron has not exhausted the domestic remedies available, thus the denial of justice claim is futile. Conversely, supporting Chevron and Texaco’s arguments, Professor Jan Paulsson provided an opinion seconding the opposite.
Paulsson affirms that a denial of justice would be a breach of the fair and equitable treatment standard and a breach of customary international law, both covered under Article II(3)(a) of the Ecuador-US BIT. Additionally, Paulsson notes that Article II(7) of the BIT establishes that Ecuador shall provide “effective means of asserting claims and enforcing rights with respect to investment, investment agreements, and investment authorizations”, the cornerstone of Chevron I award. He considers that, if Chevron’s factual allegations are true, the threshold test for denial of justice would have been crossed.
Finally, regarding the exhaustion of local remedies, Paulsson states that this rule is intended to permit states to amend a breach of the international standards. However, this does not undermine a claim of denial of justice—and therefore exhaustion is not needed—when these “offer no reasonable possibility of effective redress”.
An Ecuadorian Torpedo: Redemption or Doom?
Chevron II is founded on allegations of fraud and corruption, mirrored in the other forums of the Saga. Currently, Chevron’s EAP may represent an Ecuadorian torpedo, in the sense that it could either undermine or consolidate Ecuador’s transgressions of international law standards and its wrongful administration of justice.
The EAP does not exactly amount to an abuse of the lis pendens rule as in an Italian torpedo. Still, the constitutional proceedings could be an example of inefficiency in the Ecuadorian domestic dispute resolution system. The Constitutional Court‘s ruling could represent a final opportunity to redress violations of constitutional rights, as well as breaches of international standards of protection. However, even if such redress is granted, Ecuador faces the roughest of accusations: corruption.
The Ecuadorian courts have not been exempt from accusations of being politicized or interventionist. Moreover, Ecuador has demonized the international investment regime and investment arbitration. However, access to international arbitration does not and should not exclude the existence of reliable domestic courts that can offer effective redress and justice. The final decisions are pending, yet the Chevron Saga is already a lesson to the world on the challenges of dispute resolution and the transnational effects of fraud.
The crude reality is that a judgment tainted by fraud is as desirable as never ending proceedings. Recalling Judge Kaplan’s conclusions, the Chevron Saga represents a case where “the course of justice was perverted” and, even if the original cause was just, it has been entirely diluted, demonstrating that environmental damages are as toxic as corruption.
*Some hyperlink-sources are not translated in English. For inquiries, please contact the CILJ Blog editors or the author.
Nicely put. Many thanks!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canada pharmacies online prescriptions
canada pharmaceutical online ordering
canadianpharmacy
top rated canadian pharmacies online
Fine material. Thank you!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
best online canadian pharcharmy canadian pharmacy online canadian pharmacy without prescription canada online pharmacies
best online pharmacy
buy prescription drugs canada
prescription drugs prices
web medical information
pharmacy prescription
online canadian pharcharmy
Cheers, Useful stuff.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
best non prescription online pharmacies online pharmacies of canada canadian drug stores online canadian pharmaceuticals online
approved canadian pharmacies online
pharmacy prices compare
prescription price comparison
mexican pharmacy online
online drugstore
prescription drug price comparison
Amazing a good deal of good tips.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canadian pharmacy king canadian online pharmacies canadian pharmacy reviews canadian pharmacy online
approved canadian pharmacies online
canadapharmacy com
canadapharmacyonline com
no prior prescription required pharmacy
medical information online
canadian pharmacies without prescriptions
Great info, Thanks a lot!
http://talahicc.com/
pharmacies near me canada online pharmacies canadian drugs without prescription canadian pharmacies without an rx
safeway pharmacy
pharmacy prices
best online pharmacy stores
canadian drug store
discount pharmaceuticals
candrugstore com
Information effectively utilized.!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canadian pharmacies top best canadian pharmacies online canadian pharmacy meds london drugs canada
canadian pharmacy 365
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
canadian pharmacy no prescription
highest rated canadian pharmacies
internet pharmacy
canadian meds
You actually reported it well.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
pharmacy online store canadianpharmacy cialis canadian pharmacy northwest pharmacy
pain meds online without doctor prescription
drugs without prescription
prescription drug cost
cheap prescription drugs online
prescription prices comparison
canada pharmacies online pharmacy
Fantastic information. Thank you.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
pharmacy prices compare northwest pharmacy legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies canadian pharmacies that ship to us
online rx pharmacy
canadadrugs.com pharmacy
best canadian prescription prices
canadian rx pharmacy online
canada online pharmacy
canadian discount pharmacy
Many thanks, Plenty of data!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
discount pharmaceuticals canada drug candrugstore com online pharmacies of canada
canada pharmacies online pharmacy
canadian rx pharmacy online
canadian prescription
most reliable canadian pharmacies
canadian drug
pharmacy prices
Fantastic posts. Regards.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
online discount pharmacy canadian pharmacies discount drugs online pharmacy global pharmacy canada
compare rx prices
canada drugs online
canadian drug
medical information online
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
walmart pharmacy price check
Fantastic posts. Thanks.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
most reliable canadian pharmacies canadian pharcharmy mexican pharmacy online northwestpharmacy
online canadian discount pharmacy
most reliable canadian pharmacies
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
no prior prescription required pharmacy
canadian pharmacy meds
canadadrugs.com pharmacy
You actually reported that adequately.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
walgreens pharmacy canadian pharcharmy pharmacy price comparison london drugs canada
canada pharmacies online
pharmacy online store
highest rated canadian pharmacies
buy prescription drugs canada
buy online prescription drugs
canadian drugstore
Awesome posts. Many thanks!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
best online pharmacy stores canadian online pharmacy no prescription pharmacy canada pharmaceutical online ordering
northwest pharmacy
prescription pricing
canada drug pharmacy
canada drug pharmacy
24 hour pharmacy
buy prescription drugs canada
Valuable postings. Many thanks!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
pharmacies in canada canadian pharmaceuticals online canadapharmacyonline com canada drugs
canadian pharmacy viagra
medical information online
canadian mail order pharmacies
cialis canadian pharmacy
canadian prescription
trust pharmacy canada
Thanks. I value it.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canadianpharmacy london drugs canada mail order pharmacy canadian cialis
best online canadian pharcharmy
canadian pharma companies
online pharmacy canada
discount pharmacy online
no prescription pharmacy
canadadrugs
Kudos, Loads of info.
https://nicktambone.com/
pharmacy online store mexican pharmacies shipping to usa highest rated canadian pharmacies canadian viagra
canada online pharmacy
canadian pharmacies top best
canadian rx
get prescription online
canada pharmacy online orders
canadian rx pharmacy online
Fine advice. Appreciate it.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadian prescription canada pharmaceuticals online no prior prescription required pharmacy canada pharmaceutical online ordering
no prescription online pharmacy
rx online
canadian meds
canadian drug
cheap canadian drugs
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
You made your point.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadian family pharmacy canadian pharmacies online canada pharmacies online prescriptions canadian pharmacies that ship to us
buying prescription drugs canada
visit poster’s website
canadian pharcharmy online
canada pharmacy
canadian rx pharmacy online
prescription drug cost
Wow a good deal of excellent tips!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canadian online pharmacy reviews canada online pharmacies pharmacy online store north west pharmacy canada
online drugs
pharmacy price compare
safe canadian online pharmacies
canada pharmacies without script
canadian pharmacy online canada
<a href="http://vincent.bonduau.free.fr/?s=You+actually+stated+it+very+well.+http%3A%2F%2Fcanadianpharmacymim.com%2F+my+canadian+pharmacy+northwest+pharmacy+canadian+drug+stores+online+aarp+approved+canadian+online+pharmacies+%0D%0Apharmacy+prescription+%0D%0Acanadadrugs+%0D%0Abuy+prescription+drugs+online+%0D%0Acostco+pharmacy+pricing+%0D%0Aonline+pharmacy+without+a+prescription+%0D%0Aprescription+drugs+online+without+doctor”>legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
Thanks. Numerous facts.
http://talahicc.com/
top rated online canadian pharmacies canadian cialis canada drugs pharmacy canadian online pharmacies
get prescription online
approved canadian pharmacies online
mail order pharmacies
the canadian pharmacy
best online canadian pharcharmy
online pharmacies
Cheers. Fantastic stuff.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
drugs online canadian pharmaceuticals online canada drug prices online pharmacies of canada
get prescription online
pharmacy online
canada drugs online pharmacy
mexican pharmacy online medications
prescription price comparison
canada meds
You actually revealed that fantastically!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
best canadian prescription prices canada drugs canadapharmacyonline com aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
best canadian mail order pharmacies
canada pharmacy no prescription
most reliable canadian pharmacies
canadian drug stores online
online drugs
top rated canadian pharmacies online
Thanks a lot. Lots of posts.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
compare rx prices global pharmacy canada canada drugs online canadian pharmacies that ship to us
mexican pharmacies
ed meds online
canada meds
prescription price comparison
cheap prescription drugs online
canadian pharmacy king
You said it perfectly..
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canadian mail order pharmacies canadian drugs online pharmacy canada canada pharmacy
canadian pharmacy
canadian drugstore online
legitimate online pharmacies
cheap drugs online
safeway pharmacy
canadian pharmacies online
Regards, Lots of material.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
medication costs canadian viagra canadian rx pharmacy online aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
pharmacy prescription
pharmacy online mexico
prescription cost comparison
canada pharmacies online
best canadian pharmacies
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
Whoa many of fantastic knowledge!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canada online pharmacies canadian pharmacies-24h no prescription pharmacy north west pharmacy canada
prescription drug cost
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
rx online
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
no prescription pharmacies
Many thanks, Helpful information.
https://nicktambone.com/
canadapharmacyonline.com global pharmacy canada canadian drugs canadian pharcharmy
canadapharmacy com
prescription drug
canadian drugs without prescription
best online international pharmacies
best canadian pharmacies
highest rated canadian pharmacies
Nicely put. Thanks a lot.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
pharmacies in canada north west pharmacy canada drugs from canada canadian pharcharmy
best canadian online pharmacy
canadian pharmacy 365
drug costs
buy prescription drugs without doctor
canada pharmacies
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
Nicely put. Appreciate it.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canadian pharmacy meds canadian pharmacy online discount pharmacy canada pharmaceutical online ordering
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
canadian drugs
canadian pharmacy viagra brand
canada pharmacies
buy prescription drugs from canada
cheap prescription drugs online
Cheers! Lots of postings!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
buying prescription drugs canada canadian online pharmacies pharmacy price compare canadian pharmacies-24h
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
canadian online pharmacy
canadian online pharmacies
online drugs
online canadian discount pharmacy
canadian mail order pharmacies
Nicely put. Thank you!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
medical information online canadian pharcharmy pharmacy prices compare canada drugs online
mexican pharmacies
prescription drug assistance
canadian pharmacy viagra brand
canadian pharmacy viagra
my canadian pharmacy
canadadrugs
You made your point!
http://talahicc.com/
northwestpharmacy canada drugs canadian cialis global pharmacy canada
canadian mail order pharmacies
mexican pharmacies online
canadian pharmacy viagra
online canadian pharmacies
best canadian online pharmacy
legitimate online pharmacies
Incredible a lot of amazing info.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
prescription price comparison canada pharmaceuticals online internet pharmacy canada pharmacy online
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
canada pharmacy online no script
pharmacy online mexico
pharmacy online mexico
canadian pharmacies top best
northwest pharmacy
You said it adequately.!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canadian online pharmacies global pharmacy canada mexican pharmacies online canadian pharmacy
northwest pharmacy
canadian pharmacy viagra brand
cheap drugs online
canadian pharmacies that are legit
online pharmacy without prescription
canadian pharma companies
Wonderful data. Many thanks.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canadian pharmacy no prescription north west pharmacy canada drug prices comparison canadian pharmacies-24h
mail order pharmacy
canadapharmacyonline com
canadian drugstore reviews
highest rated canadian pharmacies
best price prescription drugs
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
Really many of helpful information.
https://nicktambone.com/
compare rx prices canadianpharmacy cheap drugs online canada drug
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
drugs online
canada drug prices
no prescription pharmacy
<a href="http://mirabiliatour.blogspot.com/ask?q=+Excellent+data.+Kudos.+https%3A%2F%2Fnicktambone.com%2F+cheap+prescription+drugs+online+canadian+pharmacies+without+an+rx+prescription+drugs+without+prior+prescription+%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fcanadianpharmacyntx.com%2F%5Dcanadian+viagra%5B%2Furl%5D+%0D%0Adiscount+pharmacy+%0D%0Acanadian+pharmacies+shipping+to+usa+%0D%0Abuy+prescription+drugs+canada+%0D%0Aoverseas+pharmacy+forum+%0D%0Abest+canadian+online+pharmacy+%0D%0Acanadian+viagra&submit=ask”>canadian drugstore reviews
no prescription pharmacies
Awesome postings. Kudos!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
mexican online pharmacies london drugs canada mexican pharmacies online mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
canadian mail order pharmacies
no prior prescription required pharmacy
cialis canadian pharmacy
overseas pharmacies
highest rated canadian pharmacies
most reliable canadian pharmacies
Thanks a lot, A lot of facts!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canada pharmacies online canadian pharmacy online medication costs canadian pharmacy online
canadadrugs
canadian discount pharmacy
drugs online
canadian prescription
prescription drugs prices
prescription drugs online without
Good postings. Many thanks.
https://nicktambone.com/
buying prescription drugs canada canada drugs online pharmacy usa canadian cialis
price prescription drugs
cheap canadian drugs
mexican pharmacies
canadianpharmacy
pharmacy prices compare
canada meds
Kudos, I enjoy this.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
board of pharmacy canada pharmaceuticals online buy prescription drugs online northwestpharmacy
drugstore online
onlinecanadianpharmacy.com
rx price comparison
drug stores near me
best canadian online pharmacy
canadian family pharmacy
You made your position extremely nicely!.
https://nicktambone.com/
canada pharmacy online no script northwestpharmacy canadian drug store canadian pharmacies online
online prescription drugs
overseas pharmacies
canadapharmacyonline.com
canada pharmacy
northwest pharmacy canada
overseas pharmacies
Regards, Lots of information!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
trusted overseas pharmacies northwest pharmacy canada drugs online online pharmacies canada
northwest pharmacy canada
canadian drugs without prescription
canadian mail order pharmacies
canadian pharmacy meds
ed meds online
pharmacy tech
You actually suggested this wonderfully!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
drugs from canada canada drugs canadian prescription drugs canada pharmacy online
legitimate online pharmacies
pharmacy price compare
mexican pharmacies online
online pharmacies no prescription
discount pharmaceuticals
buying prescription drugs canada
You said it very well..
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadian prescription trust pharmacy canada prescription drug price comparison trust pharmacy canada
best price prescription drugs
prescription prices comparison
canada pharmacies
discount pharmaceuticals
canadadrugs
canada pharmacy