After submitting its official notification to the UN Secretary-General, the withdrawal of Burundi from the Rome Statute will take effect on 27 October 2017. Meanwhile, the Burundi situation remains under consideration of preliminary examination by the Office of Prosecutor (OTP) which is focusing on alleged acts committed since April 2015. An interesting issue is how Burundi’s withdrawal affects the Burundi situation in relation to the future of the International Criminal Court (ICC). This blog post will critically discuss the application of Article 127(2) of the Rome Statute in three respects: firstly, it will evaluate whether a “situation” under preliminary examination by the OTP can be considered a “matter” under A.127(2); secondly, it will discuss Burundi’s cooperation; and thirdly, it will argue that the withdrawal of Burundi should not be a catalyst for the OTP’s preliminary examination activities.
Firstly, with Burundi’s formal notification of withdrawal, A.127(2) might apply as to the ongoing Burundi situation before the ICC. Part of this provision provides that
[Its withdrawal shall not] …prejudice in any way the continued consideration of any matter which was already under consideration by the Court prior to the date on which the withdrawal became effective.
The issue here is whether “a situation” in the OTP’s “preliminary examination” is included as “a matter under consideration”. As Schabas observes, the wording “any matter” was not fully discussed during the negotiation of the Rome Statute, indeed, there are divergent interpretations of the phrase “any matter under consideration of the court”, which can lead to different possible results from the ongoing preliminary examination situation.
If the word “court” is interpreted literally and understood in a broad manner to include the Prosecutor of the ICC then the answer to the main question (whether a situation under preliminary examination is included as a “matter”) is affirmative. Simply put, the preliminary examination of Burundi’s situation could be included as a “matter” under consideration, meaning that A.127(2) would apply and the OTP could continue their preliminary examination after Burundi’s withdrawal.
However, as Whiting mentions, this literal interpretation might put the ICC in a dilemma: supposing the preliminary examination is ongoing after the date of the effective withdrawal (i.e., 27 October 2017), there will be a preliminary examination without any apprehension or cooperation by the Burundi. In this case, it may be better for the OTP to abandon the situation.
Alternatively, a different understanding is indicated by the French and Chinese versions of A.127(2). As a commentator points out, the French version of this phrase seems to show a restricted interpretation of the word “matter” to be limited to “cases”. Therefore, a situation in the phase of preliminary examination would be excluded from the scope of “matter” meaning A.127(2) could not apply.
In addition, the text of the Chinese version (i.e., 法院已在审理中的任何事项) provides another interpretation of “matter”. Compared to the French version, the Chinese version shows an even more restricted understanding of the wording “court”. By the phrase “审理 (under consideration)”, the “court” seems to be limited to chambers, excluding the OTP of the ICC. The Chinese interpretation of “court”, also appears to restrict the scope of “matter” to “cases” and in this regard, it is similar to the interpretation of the French text.
It should be noted that the Pre-Trial Chamber of the ICC is in the ambit of “court” and the Rome Statute provides that for an investigation acting proprio motu by the OTP the Pre-Trial Chamber has to decide whether to authorise such an investigation of a situation. Therefore, a “situation” under consideration by the Pre-trial Chamber might also be implied in the scope of “matters under consideration of the court”, thus, A.127(2) could apply and Burundi’s withdrawal should not prejudice the work of the Pre-trial Chamber.
Due to the uncertainty of the interpretation of “any matter under consideration of the court” it is difficult to say that the ongoing Burundi situation under preliminary examination would definitely be included as a “matter”.
Moving on to the second issue to be addressed, even if the “matter” includes preliminary examination, A.127(2) simply imposes on Burundi a negative obligation, implied in the wording “prejudice”, not to bar the consideration of the Court, rather than a duty to cooperate with the Court. Therefore, another question is what the OTP should do in this circumstance?
Whiting suggests that it is better for the OTP to initiate an investigation of this situation based on the evidence presented before Burundi’s effective withdrawal. By doing so, another part of A.127(2) will apply. It provides that
“[Its] withdrawal shall not affect any cooperation with the Court in connection with criminal investigations and proceedings in relation to which the withdrawing State had a duty to cooperate and which were commenced prior to the date on which the withdrawal became effective…”
Accordingly, Burundi would be obliged to cooperate with the ICC in investigations after the withdrawal becomes effective.
The third and final issue is whether Burundi’s withdrawal should be a catalyst for the OTP’s preliminary examinations. The Report on Preliminary Examination Activities 2016 issued by of the OTP in November, stated that the Burundi situation is in the subject-matter (jurisdiction) assessment phase. However, the OTP addresses:
“According to its legal assessment, the Office could also initiate investigations at least during this one-year period. The withdrawal of Burundi would not affect its duty to cooperate with the Court in connection with criminal investigations and proceedings commenced prior the date on which the withdrawal becomes effective.”
This statement indicates that the OTP will submit the situation to the Pre-Trial Chamber who must authorise an investigation within eleven months. Although it is unknown whether the withdrawal was a catalyst for the OTP’s legal assessment, it shows that the Burundi situation will be one of its priorities.
Even if all factual and legal requirements are satisfied, then there would be doubt as to whether this situation should be prioritised. Considering the budget in 2017, resources for the OTP are limited and if the OTP makes this situation its priority then other situations would be delayed. The Burundi situation should not be prioritised simply due to the State’s withdrawal.
The 2016 Policy paper on case selection and prioritisation might provide guidance for the assessment of whether to focus on this situation. One of its criteria is “the impact and the ability of the Office to pursue cases involving opposing parties to a conflict in parallel or on a sequential basis”. Considering its withdrawal, Burundi might not cooperate with the ICC to ensure the appearance of suspects working for its government before the Court, despite being obliged to do so. Without cooperation, it seems that no individual in a potential case would be prosecuted before the ICC. The OTP might be less capable of pursuing cases involving the Burundi government.
Yet, if the OTP successfully justified the prioritisation of this situation and the Pre-Trial Chamber authorised the investigation of this situation, its authorisation might imply that a State party whose leaders might be defendants cannot avoid the ICC by withdrawing from the Rome Statute.
However, the ICC’s prosecution of the Burundi situation may not have a lasting effect, and perhaps focusing on the Afghanistan and Iraq/UK situations would save the ICC’s reputation in the long term.
To sum up, the application of the A.127(2) of the Rome Statute is uncertain in the preliminary examination of the Burundi situation. Furthermore, due to Burundi’s withdrawal, the ICC has to be prepared for long-term criticism if the Pre-Trial Chamber authorises an investigation of the Burundi situation in the following eleven months.
Regards, Awesome stuff.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
pharmacy online
aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
northwest pharmacy canada
trust pharmacy canada
With thanks! Numerous tips.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canadian pharmacy no prescription needed canadian pharmacy canada pharmacy aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
prescription drugs without prior prescription
canadian rx pharmacy online
canada pharmacy online reviews
canadian online pharmacy
online pharmacy canada
canada pharmacies online prescriptions
Reliable postings. Kudos.
https://nicktambone.com/
pharmacy near me canada drugs mexican pharmacy online medications canadian pharmacies
pharmacy price comparison
prescription drugs without prior prescription
prescription prices comparison
buy cialis
prescription online
trust pharmacy canada
Amazing stuff. Cheers.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies canada online pharmacies canadadrugs.com pharmacy canadian pharmacies online
canadian prescriptions
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
safeway pharmacy
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
best online pharmacy
canada online pharmacy
Very good info. With thanks!
https://nicktambone.com/
canadian meds canadian drugs canada meds canada pharmacy
cheap drugs online
mexican online pharmacies
online pharmacies
pharmacy price comparison
web medical information
visit poster’s website
Nicely put. Thank you!
http://talahicc.com/
canadian pharmacy viagra canadian online pharmacies canadian pharmacy meds canada drug
pharmacy price comparison
canada drugs
highest rated canadian pharmacies
canadian drug store
online canadian discount pharmacy
buying prescription drugs canada
Superb information, With thanks!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
canadian pharmacies top best canadian pharmacies-24h online discount pharmacy canadian drugs
buy drugs online
pharmacy without dr prescriptions
canadian prescription drugs
canadian pharmacy reviews
overseas pharmacy forum
international pharmacies that ship to the usa
Nicely put, Regards!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canadian mail order pharmacies mexican pharmacies shipping to usa trust pharmacy canada online pharmacies canada
cheap canadian drugs
top rated canadian pharmacies online
pharmacies in canada
prescription drug assistance
canadian pharmacies online
prescription drugs without prior prescription
Regards, Helpful stuff.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
prescription drug canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy uk delivery canadian pharmacy
canada pharmacy online reviews
northwestpharmacy
canadian drugstore
prescription drugs online without
canadian cialis
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
Nicely put, Regards.
http://talahicc.com/
online pharmacy canada mexican pharmacies shipping to usa northwest pharmacy canada pharmacy online
prescription online
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
canadian pharmacies
best online pharmacy
no prescription pharmacy
online pharmacies
Awesome posts. Kudos.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadapharmacy com london drugs canada canadian pharmacy top rated canadian pharmacies online
prescription cost comparison
canadian pharmacy
canada pharmacies online pharmacy
canada drugs pharmacy
safeway pharmacy
canadianpharmacy
Wonderful stuff, With thanks!
http://talahicc.com/
canadian meds canada drugs online international pharmacies that ship to the usa canadian pharmacies
legitimate online pharmacies
buy prescription drugs from canada
canadian discount pharmacy
canadian prescription drugs
canadian prescription drugs
no prior prescription required pharmacy
You actually suggested it perfectly!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
northwestpharmacy online pharmacies of canada discount prescription drugs online canada pharmacy
pain meds online without doctor prescription
canadian pharmacy 365
no prescription pharmacy
canadian prescription drugstore
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
my canadian pharmacy
Many thanks! A good amount of stuff.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canada meds canadian pharmaceuticals online canadian drugs mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
discount pharmacy
canadian pharmacies online prescriptions
canadian viagra
canadian pharmacies online prescriptions
no prescription pharmacy
online pharmacy no prescription
Well spoken indeed! !
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
ed meds online canadian pharmacies canadian pharmacies that are legit canadian drugs
canadapharmacyonline.com
online canadian pharmacy
pharmacy online
prescription drug price comparison
canada pharmacies
24 hour pharmacy
Amazing content. Kudos.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canadian drug aarp approved canadian online pharmacies mexican pharmacy online global pharmacy canada
overseas pharmacies
best online pharmacy stores
canadapharmacyonline com
canadian pharmacies that are legit
canada online pharmacy
prescription pricing
Amazing lots of superb knowledge.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
buy prescription drugs without doctor canada drug canadian prescription drugs canadian pharmacies without an rx
pharmacy prices compare
prescription drugs canada
best price prescription drugs
online pharmacy without a prescription
online pharmacies
canadian pharmacy meds
Kudos! Numerous info!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies canadian pharmacies best canadian pharmacies canadian pharmaceuticals online
canada pharmacy online no script
canadian pharmacy reviews
canadian drug stores online
meds online
pharmacy online store
canada pharmacy no prescription
You’ve made your position very effectively!.
http://talahicc.com/
canadian pharmacy reviews canadian pharmacies that ship to us visit poster’s website canadian pharmacies
canadian prescription drugs
drug price
online pharmacy reviews
mexican pharmacies online
most reliable canadian pharmacies
prescription drugs online without
Nicely put. With thanks.
https://nicktambone.com/
us pharmacy no prior prescription canada pharmacy online drug costs canadian pharmacy
online discount pharmacy
discount pharmacy
best online international pharmacies
buy prescription drugs without doctor
canada meds
meds online
Valuable posts. Thank you!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
online pharmacy no prescription needed canadian drugs buy prescription drugs without doctor canada pharmacy
online pharmacy without prescription
canada pharmacy
canadian drugs without prescription
pharmacy price compare
canadian pharmacies online prescriptions
canadian online pharmacy reviews
You said it nicely.!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
prescription drugs online without doctor canadian pharmacies that ship to us mexican pharmacies online northwestpharmacy
compare prescription prices
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
pharmacy prices compare
prescription drugs canada
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
buy prescription drugs without doctor
You made the point.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
cheap prescription drugs canadian cialis canadian prescription drugs canada drugs
drug price
ed meds online
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
canadian mail order pharmacies
prescription drugs online without doctor
cialis online
Reliable information. Many thanks!
http://talahicc.com/
safe canadian online pharmacies canadian pharcharmy canada pharmacies online pharmacy mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
best canadian pharmacies
buying drugs canada
no prescription pharmacy
canadian pharmacy reviews
canadian online pharmacy
most reliable canadian pharmacies
Thanks, I value this!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
buying drugs canada london drugs canada best online international pharmacies canadian pharcharmy
canadian cialis
canada pharmacy online orders
drugs online
the canadian pharmacy
best online pharmacies canada
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
Terrific information. Thanks a lot.
http://talahicc.com/
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa canada drug king pharmacy canadian drugs
discount pharmacy online
legitimate online pharmacies
online canadian pharmacies
pharmacy near me
canadian rx
canada pharmacies online prescriptions
Kudos! Numerous tips!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
online discount pharmacy canadian pharmacies online no prescription online pharmacy canadian pharmacy
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
visit poster’s website
trust pharmacy canada
online canadian pharmacies
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
pharmacy prices
This is nicely said! !
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canada pharmacy online reviews canadian pharmacies without an rx canadian drug store canadian pharmacy online
best online canadian pharcharmy
my canadian pharmacy
discount prescription drugs online
canadian pharmacy
discount drugs online pharmacy
canada drug
You said it nicely..
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
ed meds online top rated canadian pharmacies online best canadian mail order pharmacies top rated canadian pharmacies online
overseas pharmacies
buy prescription drugs canada
prescription cost comparison
online prescription drugs
buying drugs canada
canada pharmacy online
You mentioned it really well!
https://nicktambone.com/
best online pharmacies canada canada online pharmacies pharmacy price comparison canada online pharmacies
canadian drugs
ed meds online
pharmacy near me
mail order pharmacy
mexican online pharmacies
canadian pharmacy meds
Many thanks! Quite a lot of facts.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
buy prescription drugs from canada canada online pharmacies prescription prices comparison aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
online canadian discount pharmacy
canada drug pharmacy
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
web medical information
buy prescription drugs from canada
online pharmacy usa
You have made your point!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
prescription drugs online without doctor online pharmacies of canada drugs online canadian pharcharmy
online rx pharmacy
canada pharmacies
canada pharmacy online no script
highest rated canadian pharmacies
compare prescription prices
canadian pharmacy viagra brand
You actually reported that terrifically!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
prescription cost canada drugs online pharmacy canada pharmacy online
online canadian pharmacy
canadian family pharmacy
safe canadian online pharmacies
buy online prescription drugs
pharmacy cost comparison
<a href="http://inv4zi0n.blogspot.com/mailto:viiih.dellicious@gmail.com?subject=canadian+pharmacies+online+tofs&body=+Great+stuff.+Cheers%21+http%3A%2F%2Fwww.canadianpharmacymsn.com%2F+canada+pharmacy+online+orders+canadianpharmacy+canadian+pharcharmy+online+%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.canadianpharmacymsn.com%2F%5Dcanadian+pharmacies-24h%5B%2Furl%5D+%0D%0Abuy+cialis+%0D%0Acanadian+drugstore+online+%0D%0Aonline+pharmacy+no+prescription+needed+%0D%0Atop+rated+canadian+pharmacies+online+%0D%0Adiscount+pharmaceuticals+%0D%0Abest+price+prescription+drugs&submit=Enviar”>24 hour pharmacy
You actually suggested it really well.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
24 hour pharmacy canada pharmacy canadian pharmacies that ship to us canada pharmaceutical online ordering
pharmacy online mexico
mexican pharmacy online medications
pharmacy online
canadian viagra
canadian pharmacies that are legit
canadian pharmacy without prescription
Thank you! I like it!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
best canadian pharmacies trust pharmacy canada drugs from canada canadian cialis
canada drugs
best online canadian pharcharmy
canadapharmacyonline.com
canada pharmacies online prescriptions
us pharmacy no prior prescription
mail order pharmacy
Whoa lots of great information.
https://nicktambone.com/
buying drugs canada online pharmacies of canada pharmacy canada canada pharmacy
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
medication costs
online prescription drugs
best online international pharmacies
canadian pharmacy viagra
canadian drugstore
Seriously a lot of very good advice!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
buying prescription drugs canada top rated canadian pharmacies online web medical information canada drugs
canadian pharmacies online prescriptions
canada pharmacy online
drugs for sale
canadian prescription drugstore
drugs for sale
cheap prescription drugs online
Appreciate it. Loads of knowledge!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
northwest pharmacy canada canadian pharmacies without an rx pharmacy online canadian pharmacies
best online pharmacies canada
costco pharmacy pricing
cialis canadian pharmacy
no prior prescription required pharmacy
online pharmacy no prescription needed
discount prescription drugs online
This is nicely put! !
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
mexican pharmacy online canadian pharmacy safe canadian online pharmacies northwest pharmacy
canadian prescription
canadian viagra
drug stores near me
pharmacy prices compare
online pharmacy reviews
prescription drugs without doctor approval
Nicely put. Many thanks!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canadian pharmacies that are legit canadian cialis online pharmacy no prescription needed canadian viagra
canada pharmacy
candrugstore com
pharmacy canada
canadian pharmacies online
pharmacy online store
canada online pharmacies
Good info. Appreciate it!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
prescription drugs without prior prescription north west pharmacy canada canada pharmacy online orders canada online pharmacies
price prescription drugs
canada online pharmacy
buy prescription drugs without doctor
mail order pharmacy
pharmacy online store
online pharmacy no prescription
You explained this superbly!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
best online pharmacies canada canadian pharcharmy mexican online pharmacies mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
canadian pharmacy viagra brand
canadianpharmacy
canada drugs online pharmacy
canada pharmacy online
canadian pharcharmy online
compare rx prices
Good data. Many thanks!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
buy online prescription drugs canada pharmacy online pharmacy canada pharmacy
pharmacy drug store
prescription drug price comparison
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
buying prescription drugs canada
canadian online pharmacies
canadian pharmacies
You revealed it terrifically.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
drugs for sale canada pharmaceuticals online canadian pharmacies that are legit canadian online pharmacies
canadian pharmacy reviews
canadian rx pharmacy online
mexican online pharmacies
top rated online canadian pharmacies
canadian drugs
compare rx prices
Useful info. Many thanks!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canada drug prices canada drug reputable canadian mail order pharmacies canada pharmacy online
drugs without prescription
canadian mail order pharmacies
buy prescription drugs without doctor
canada drugs online
canadian pharmacy online
canada drugs online pharmacy
Regards! Terrific stuff.
http://talahicc.com/
canadian online pharmacy reviews canada pharmacy best canadian online pharmacy canadian viagra
online canadian pharmacies
drug stores near me
legitimate online pharmacies
canadian drug store
canadian pharmacy online
canadian discount pharmacy
Very good data, Thank you!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canada pharmacies prescription drugs canadian pharmacy canadian family pharmacy canada drugs
online pharmacy canada
canadian drugstore
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
canadian pharmacy no prescription
drugs without prescription
canada pharmacy online reviews
You said that wonderfully!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
trusted overseas pharmacies canadian online pharmacy discount pharmacy online top rated canadian pharmacies online
canadian prescription
prescription drug assistance
prescription cost
cheap prescription drugs online
overseas pharmacies
drugs without prescription
You actually explained it superbly!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
online drugs canada pharmaceuticals online no prescription online pharmacy aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
online canadian pharmacy
buy drugs online
discount drugs online pharmacy
approved canadian pharmacies online
online rx pharmacy
global pharmacy canada