I. Introduction
Debates about the functions of adjudication in the sphere of international law have not been scarce, Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS) traditionally occupying the main stage. Given as much, it should not come as a surprise that the recent EU proposal for an Investment Court under the TTIP generated heated discussions, for it does indeed turn the tables in the field of ISDS. Amidst such discussions, the present note addresses the issue from a very specific perspective in that it shifts the paradigm to the contribution that each mechanism makes to the international rule of law.
II. Furtherance of the Rule of Law as a Function of Adjudicating Bodies
At the outset, it should be clarified that the rule of law is, in the context of the theory of dispute settlement, perceived in its formal guise. That is, as a principle that serves to preserve a certain level of predictability so as to reaffirm and reinforce the law’s ‘dependable guideposts for self-directed action’, as best expressed by Lon Fuller. In particular, the rule of law seeks to ‘subject […] people’s conduct to the guidance of general rules by which they may themselves orient their behaviour’. According to Fuller, as particularly clarified by Matthew Kramer, it does so by positing eight requirements: (i) governance by general norms; (ii) public ascertainability; (iii) prospectivity; (iv) perspicuity; (v) non-contradictoriness and non-conflictingness; (vi) compliability; (vii) steadiness over time; and (viii) congruence between formulation and implementation.
At this point, two caveats should be made: first, that predictability obtains by degrees. Ergo, it should not be expected that a certain dispute settlement system will bring about an instant metamorphosis in the rule of law. Second, that sustaining the rule of law is a noble task only insofar as the law, itself, sufficiently reflects fundamental societal values; and indeed, the assumption that the TTIP Court is established in order to enforce valuable substantive standards should not be made lightly. Still, challenging those standards conveys that the entire field of investment law is not sensible and functional, a point which can be expanded on in a separate note.
III. ISDS and the International Rule of Law
International lawyers arguing for the compatibility of ISDS with the rule of law have generally based their contentions on the following premises: first, that the standards of protection of foreign investment under Bilateral Investment Treaties (BIT) are worth sustaining; and second, that the system’s purpose is not to protect the rights of corporations but rather to enable States to make reliable promises to them.
Fighting the first premise would require a socio-economic analysis which, as noted, lies beyond the reach of this note. The second inherent assumption however is by and large assessable; it essentially suggests that arbitral tribunals promote the rule of law because they allow states to make reliable promises to foreigners. Finding themselves in a predictable legal environment, foreigners are induced to invest larger sums for longer periods, bringing prosperity to the host state.
The tribunal in Saipem v. Bangladesh, moving along those lines, stated that reliance on previous case-law may be mandated by a ‘[…]duty […] to meet the legitimate expectations of the community of States and investors towards certainty of the rule of law.’ Yet, the actuality is that absent a strict stare decisis doctrine in investment law, tribunals will not necessarily ascribe authoritative weight to previous awards. As a result, investors may or may not be given access to a tribunal by virtue of an MFN clause, and they may or may not be able to litigate their contract claims under an International Investment Agreement (IIA). In turn, states are insecure as to the possibility of facing claims on said bases.
Likewise, the absence of effective mechanisms for the avoidance of parallel proceedings may lead to Lauder-type scenarios or double counting of remedies, creating a setting that is far from predictable, be it for the investor or the state. The vast network of around 3000 IIAs opens up a plethora of possibilities for investors to pursue parallel claims against states, especially where shareholders’ claims for indirect injury are permitted. Further, claims arising out of the same facts are increasingly pursued in parallel before investment and commercial arbitration tribunals.
Predictability would, lastly, necessitate consistency in correctly interpreting a set of rules. In other words, teleological or other extra-legal considerations should not prompt contra legem interpretations. Arbitrators have not escaped criticism in that respect, be it for judicial activism or for being motivated by the possibility of being reappointed by the parties, rather than promoting justice.
To sum up, and to put it in Kramer’s terms, ISDS is rightly criticized for lagging behind in non-contradictoriness, steadiness over time, and congruence between formulation and implementation of its norms. It is these defects that the TTIP Investment Court System must dispose of.
IV. The TTIP Investment Court and the Road Ahead
The TTIP investment chapter features a number of provisions that go beyond traditional investment treaties. Indicatively, it requires investors to furnish evidence that parallel proceedings by subsidiaries or controlling entities are not pursued before other fora; it provides that all hearings and documents shall be made public; and it designates a mechanism for early dismissal of unfounded claims. At the very core of the system however lie two main features: the existence of a standing adjudicative body and the possibility of appeal.
In concreto, the TTIP establishes a ‘Tribunal of First Instance’ composed of 15 judges, appointed for a six-year term, renewable once. Its members are appointed by the Committee on Services and Investment, five of them being nationals of EU member-states, an equal five being US nationals, and the remaining five seats being reserved for nationals of third countries. The members must demonstrate expertise in trade, investment and public international law. Tribunals on each occasion consist of three adjudicators, one of each eligible nationality, the ‘third country national’ presiding; members are appointed on a rotation basis by the President of the Tribunal of First Instance, and must not be involved in any pending case. Lastly, they receive moderate salaries.
The ‘Appeal Tribunal’ in turn consists of six members, two of each designated nationality (US, EU, third countries). The grounds for appeal are (i) error in interpretation or application of the law, (ii) manifest error in appreciation of facts and (iii) the grounds for annulment listed under Article 52 of the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes Convention.
All the features laid out above represent a branching out to successful dispute settlement mechanisms, and in particular to the WTO Dispute Settlement Body. The latter, while not free of mild criticism, has generally been commemorated by its users during its 21 years of existence, and largely, its success comes encased within the work of the Appellate Body. The supreme judicial organ of the WTO has for the most part sustained the rule of law, providing a body of consistent jurisprudence yet not hesitating to depart from previous reports where ‘cogent reasons’ so mandate, ensuring congruence between formulation and practice of the law. Further, the limited influence of the parties on the selection of Panelists has generally managed to repeal impartiality concerns.
Equally, the Investment Court System disconnects adjudication from party autonomy, rightly so for a system that engages the public interest this much. Indeed, while arbitrators answer to the parties, judges answer to the public. In the same vein, moderate salaries have the capacity to filter out purely financially driven adjudicators, while rigid requirements on the amount of cases handled in parallel with those under the TTIP seek to safeguard the principles of impartiality and independence. Additionally, the existence of an appellate court empowered to review the merits of a tribunal’s decision ensures non-contradictoriness, perspicuity and congruence between the letter of the law and its application.
Yet, the EU proposal does present a number of challenges: it does not clearly specify how the Trade and Investment Commission is to appoint the fifteen members of the Tribunal, urging investors to voice concerns about substantial state involvement, potentially leading to appointment of pro-state adjudicators. Further, the proposal envisages the possibility of binding treaty interpretations offered by the TTIP member-states, even pending a dispute. This brings up unpleasant memories from the Pope & Talbot saga, which tested NAFTA’s prospectivity. Lastly, requiring judges not to be at all involved in other investment cases excessively narrows down the spectrum of eligible judges, seeing as the vast majority of investment experts regularly sit as arbitrators or act as counsel.
V. Conclusion
‘There is little use in going to law with the devil while the court is held in hell’, said Humphrey O’Sullivan in 1831. Those holding onto that logic in order to defend ISDS create – and part from – the incorrect premise that domestic courts are by necessity ‘hell’. Yet, ISDS itself admittedly remains far from ‘heaven’; and what this note has put forward is that, in turn, the EU Investment Court proposal represents a form of ‘Midgard’ for the rule of law in the international investment context.
You stated that terrifically!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
prescription price comparison
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
online pharmacy reviews
canadian pharmacies without an rx
Kudos! I value it.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
prescription pricing canada pharmacy online buying drugs canada canada drugs
best online pharmacy stores
drugs from canada
pain meds online without doctor prescription
canadian pharmacy
prescription drugs without prior prescription
pharmacy online store
You stated this terrifically!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canadian drugs canada online pharmacies online discount pharmacy aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
online prescription drugs
costco pharmacy pricing
canada pharmacies online
online pharmacies
pharmacy online store
canadian mail order pharmacies
Valuable knowledge. Many thanks!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
my canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacies canada online pharmacies aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
canadian mail order pharmacies
medication costs
online prescription drugs
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
online pharmacy without a prescription
canadian drug stores online
You have made your point!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
no prescription pharmacies canadian pharmacy online best canadian mail order pharmacies top rated canadian pharmacies online
online pharmacy usa
no prior prescription required pharmacy
canadian pharcharmy online
cheap canadian drugs
canadian family pharmacy
canadian pharcharmy online
Thanks, Helpful information!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canadian discount pharmacy canada pharmaceutical online ordering discount pharmacy online canadian online pharmacy
discount pharmacy
cialis online
mexican pharmacy online
prescription drugs online without
canada pharmacy online no script
compare prescription prices
Regards, Wonderful information.
http://talahicc.com/
canada drugs online pharmacy canadian pharmacies that ship to us canada drugs online pharmacy trust pharmacy canada
canada pharmacy online no script
canadian prescription drugs
online drugs
no prescription pharmacies
pharmacy near me
mexican pharmacies
Cheers! I appreciate it.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
canada online pharmacy aarp approved canadian online pharmacies canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs canada pharmaceuticals online
canada drugs online
us pharmacy no prior prescription
buy prescription drugs online
canada meds
drugs from canada
buying prescription drugs canada
You’ve made your point.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
global pharmacy canada canadian pharmacies-24h best canadian pharmacies northwest pharmacy
online drugs
canadian drugstore reviews
canada pharmacy no prescription
my canadian pharmacy
candrugstore com
buying prescription drugs canada
Cheers! Fantastic stuff.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
canada pharmacy online orders canadian pharmacies without an rx best canadian prescription prices canada pharmacy
canada pharmacies
pharmacy cost comparison
online drugs
canadian meds
canada pharmacy online no script
canadadrugs
Many thanks! Loads of tips!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
internet pharmacy mexican pharmacies shipping to usa mexican pharmacy online north west pharmacy canada
canadapharmacy com
best online international pharmacies
prescription drugs without prior prescription
prescription drugs prices
prescription drugs online without
canada drugs pharmacy
You actually mentioned that really well!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadian pharmacy no prescription canada drugs online canada pharmacies online pharmacy canadian drugs
prescription price comparison
safe canadian online pharmacies
canadapharmacyonline com
northwest pharmacy canada
best canadian pharmacies
candrugstore com
Thank you. I appreciate this.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
pharmacy prices compare canada drug online discount pharmacy canada online pharmacies
canadian drugstore reviews
buy online prescription drugs
canadian prescription drugstore
best canadian mail order pharmacies
prescription pricing
canadian drugstore
Incredible plenty of beneficial info.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
cialis canadian pharmacy canadian cialis canada drugs canadian pharmacy
top rated canadian pharmacies online
cheap canadian drugs
discount drugs online pharmacy
legitimate online pharmacies
drugs without prescription
prescription price comparison
Thanks a lot! An abundance of content.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
prescription drugs canada canadian cialis cheap drugs online canadian drugs
prescription cost comparison
buy prescription drugs canada
online pharmacies canada
canadian drug store
canada pharmacy no prescription
us pharmacy no prior prescription
Kudos. Ample tips.
http://talahicc.com/
most reliable canadian pharmacies canadian viagra canadian drug stores online aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
northwest pharmacy canada
legitimate online pharmacies
online discount pharmacy
discount pharmacy online
canada drug pharmacy
pharmacy prices
With thanks! Plenty of info.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
online pharmacies no prescription canadian pharmacies that ship to us canadian drug canadian drugs
buy cialis
us pharmacy no prior prescription
online pharmacy reviews
drug prices comparison
online canadian pharmacy
approved canadian pharmacies online
Reliable tips. Cheers.
https://nicktambone.com/
online pharmacy no prescription top rated canadian pharmacies online online drugstore canadian cialis
canadian online pharmacy reviews
best price prescription drugs
ed meds online
canadianpharmacy
canadian pharmacy without prescription
canada pharmacies online pharmacy
Regards. I enjoy this.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
get prescription online online pharmacies of canada canada pharmacies without script canada online pharmacies
pharmacy without dr prescriptions
prescription online
buy prescription drugs online
walgreens pharmacy
pharmacy online store
rx online
You suggested it perfectly.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
drugs without prescription northwest pharmacy online canadian pharmacy canadian online pharmacies
canadapharmacy com
canada drug prices
pharmacy without dr prescriptions
discount prescription drugs online
discount prescription drug
canada pharmacy online no script
Seriously a good deal of valuable facts!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
online drugs canadian pharmacy online northwest pharmacy canada canadian pharmacies-24h
canada pharmacy no prescription
canadian prescription
mexican pharmacies
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
online pharmacy
top rated canadian pharmacies online
You actually expressed that wonderfully.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
best canadian mail order pharmacies canadian pharmaceuticals online online rx pharmacy canadian pharmacy
cheap prescription drugs
canada drug
canadian pharmacies online prescriptions
compare prescription prices
canadian drugstore reviews
pharmacy drug store
This is nicely expressed! !
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadian online pharmacies canadian pharmacy online canadian pharmacies that are legit canada pharmaceuticals online
mexican pharmacies online
trusted overseas pharmacies
online rx pharmacy
best price prescription drugs
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
canada pharmacies
Thanks a lot, Valuable information.
http://talahicc.com/
prescription prices comparison northwestpharmacy buying prescription drugs canada northwest pharmacy
canadian mail order pharmacies
canadian drug
prescription drugs online without
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
mexican pharmacy online medications
canadapharmacy com
Cheers! Wonderful stuff!
http://talahicc.com/
canadian pharmacy without prescription canada drugs drug prices comparison canadian online pharmacy
canadian pharmacy no prescription
best canadian prescription prices
prescription drugs prices
canada drugs online
mexican pharmacies online
canadian pharmacies that are legit
Many thanks. I like it.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
canadian prescription drugs canadian pharmaceuticals online cialis online canadian pharmacies that ship to us
canadian pharmacy meds
canadian drug
pharmacy prices compare
canadapharmacyonline com
best online international pharmacies
canada pharmacies online pharmacy
Truly plenty of valuable information!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
drugstore online northwestpharmacy ed meds online canadian pharmacies online
no prior prescription required pharmacy
canada drug prices
canadian drug store
canadian online pharmacies
pharmacy online mexico
canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
Useful material. Thanks!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
trusted overseas pharmacies canada drugs pharmacies near me mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
buy drugs online
canadapharmacy com
us pharmacy no prior prescription
canadian rx pharmacy online
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
canadian drug stores online
Helpful information. Cheers!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
online pharmacy usa canadianpharmacy canada pharmacy online reviews northwest pharmacy
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
canadian drugs
canadian meds
canada online pharmacy
cialis canadian pharmacy
the canadian pharmacy
Whoa tons of terrific tips!
https://nicktambone.com/
canadian drugstore reviews canadian pharmacies without an rx canadian drugs canada pharmaceuticals online
best canadian mail order pharmacies
best canadian online pharmacy
pharmacy canada
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
<a href="http://mirabiliatour.blogspot.com/ask?q=You+actually+stated+it+terrifically%21+https%3A%2F%2Fnicktambone.com%2F+canadapharmacy+com+global+pharmacy+canada+online+drugs+%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.canadianpharmacymsn.com%2F%5Dcanadian+pharcharmy%5B%2Furl%5D+%0D%0Asafeway+pharmacy+%0D%0Aoverseas+pharmacy+forum+%0D%0Acanadadrugs+%0D%0Acanada+meds+%0D%0Acanadian+drugstore+reviews+%0D%0Atrusted+overseas+pharmacies&submit=ask”>canadian pharmacy viagra brand
canadian pharmacy online canada
Thanks a lot. Loads of content!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
pharmacy prescription canadian pharmaceuticals online canadian pharmacies that are legit canada pharmacy online
canadian pharmacies top best
pharmacy cost comparison
mexican pharmacies
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
canadian pharmacy reviews
pharmacy near me
Nicely put. Many thanks.
http://talahicc.com/
cialis canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacies without an rx discount prescription drug canadian cialis
canadian cialis
canada pharmacy
canada pharmacy online no script
canada pharmacies without script
highest rated canadian pharmacies
no prior prescription required pharmacy
Kudos! Plenty of tips!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
walmart pharmacy price check online pharmacies of canada online pharmacy without a prescription canadian online pharmacies
canadian pharmacy meds
internet pharmacy
internet pharmacy
web medical information
canadian pharmacy online
no prescription pharmacy
Thanks a lot, A good amount of data.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
online drugs mexican pharmacies shipping to usa drug stores near me aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
best canadian mail order pharmacies
canada pharmacy online no script
prescription drugs without doctor approval
prescription drug assistance
canadian pharmacy meds
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
Regards, Plenty of advice.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
prescription cost global pharmacy canada canada online pharmacy canadian pharmacies online
online canadian pharmacy
canadian prescription drugstore
canadian pharcharmy online
safeway pharmacy
buying drugs canada
canadadrugs.com pharmacy
Really loads of beneficial facts.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
prescription drug cost canadian pharmacies online canadian pharmacy meds northwest pharmacy
prescription drugs prices
overseas pharmacy forum
canadian prescription
drug prices comparison
prescription drugs online without
canada drug prices
Regards! Ample knowledge.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canadian pharmacies top best canada pharmaceutical online ordering pharmacy cost comparison canadian viagra
online pharmacy reviews
canada meds
global pharmacy canada
get prescription online
canadian rx
prescription online
Fine material. Regards.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
mexican pharmacy online canada pharmacy online pharmacy online mexico canada pharmaceuticals online
online pharmacy canada
online pharmacy
canadian drug store
canada meds
discount pharmacy
online drugstore
Really plenty of superb material.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canadian prescriptions canadian online pharmacies canadian pharmacy viagra canada drug
canadian drug
discount prescription drug
canadian discount pharmacy
online canadian pharcharmy
discount pharmaceuticals
canadian pharmacies
Many thanks. Wonderful stuff.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canadian drug store canadian pharmaceuticals online medical information online trust pharmacy canada
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
pharmacy near me
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
online canadian pharmacy
pharmacy online store
prescription cost comparison
Truly plenty of terrific data.
http://talahicc.com/
prescription drug assistance canadian pharmacies without an rx canadian drugstore reviews canada online pharmacies
discount drugs online pharmacy
best canadian prescription prices
canada meds
mexican pharmacy online medications
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
pharmacy online mexico
You actually expressed this effectively.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canada drugs online canadian pharmacies canadian pharmacies online prescriptions global pharmacy canada
24 hour pharmacy
canadian pharmacies
best canadian prescription prices
canadian pharmacy viagra brand
cialis canadian pharmacy
canadian pharmacy king
Reliable information. Appreciate it!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa top rated canadian pharmacies online buy cialis canadian pharmacies-24h
cialis canadian pharmacy
drugs online
northwest pharmacy
canadian pharmacy without prescription
canadian prescription
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
Regards, I enjoy it!
https://nicktambone.com/
canadian pharmacy 365 london drugs canada canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs canadian pharmacy online
rx price comparison
canadian pharmacy meds
buying prescription drugs canada
canadian pharmacy viagra brand
best online pharmacies canada
canada pharmacy online
Many thanks, Ample tips!
https://nicktambone.com/
compare rx prices london drugs canada canadian pharmacies online canadian pharmacies-24h
pharmacies near me
best online pharmacy stores
online pharmacy no prescription
mexican pharmacy online medications
canadapharmacyonline com
canadian prescriptions
Whoa tons of fantastic info!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
prescription drugs without prior prescription canadian online pharmacy canada drug prices northwest pharmacy
best canadian pharmacies
compare prescription prices
pharmacy online
canadian prescription drugstore
online canadian pharmacies
trust pharmacy canada
Amazing lots of very good information.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
discount pharmacy online canadian pharmacies online cheap prescription drugs online pharmacies of canada
cheap prescription drugs online
canada drugs pharmacy
pharmacy without dr prescriptions
canadian prescription drugstore
drug price
cheap prescription drugs online
Beneficial content. Appreciate it.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
buy prescription drugs canada canadian pharmacies pharmacy online mexico north west pharmacy canada
mexican pharmacies
canada pharmacies online prescriptions
canadian pharmacies online prescriptions
prescription drug assistance
board of pharmacy
online pharmacy without prescription
Great forum posts. Many thanks.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
prescription drugs prices canadian pharmacies-24h cialis canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacies online
online rx pharmacy
best canadian pharmacies
online pharmacy canada
drug stores near me
online pharmacy no prescription needed
prescription prices comparison
You stated it well.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadian meds online pharmacies of canada canadian pharmacy no prescription needed canada drug
buy prescription drugs canada
cheap prescription drugs
discount prescription drugs online
canada meds
canadadrugs
canada pharmacy online
You made the point!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
online prescription drugs online pharmacies of canada trusted overseas pharmacies canadian pharmacies that ship to us
pharmacy prices compare
discount pharmacy
compare prescription prices
pharmacy prices
<a href="http://mirabiliatour.blogspot.com/ask?q=+Many+thanks.+Quite+a+lot+of+material%21++http%3A%2F%2Fcanadianonlinepharmacynnm.com%2F+prescription+without+a+doctor%27s+prescription+canadianpharmacy+drugs+for+sale+%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fcanadianpharmaciesnnm.com%2F%5Dcanadian+cialis%5B%2Furl%5D+%0D%0Aprescription+drugs+without+prior+prescription+%0D%0Acheap+prescription+drugs+online+%0D%0Abest+canadian+pharmacies+%0D%0Acanadian+drugstore+reviews+%0D%0Apharmacy+price+comparison+%0D%0Acanada+drugs&submit=ask”>canadian online pharmacy
canada pharmacies without script
Excellent content. Appreciate it!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
cheap canadian drugs london drugs canada canadian drugstore online north west pharmacy canada
online pharmacies canada
canadapharmacyonline com
cheap canadian drugs
canadian rx pharmacy online
best online pharmacy
pharmacy online mexico