Non-refoulement refers to the idea that those fleeing persecution on account of their ‘race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion’ should not be forced to return where they will be subjected to further persecution; fundamental to both the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees and the 1967 Protocol to the convention. Sustained state practice and vested interest groups among key UNHRC donor states have rendered the principle ineffectual. Given present events in Europe, it is important to articulate a consolidated stance on refugee policy to keep the institution of asylum from spiralling into complete collapse – as it historically already has.
1. A crisis of foresight
National policy on refugees is necessarily encumbered with two strands of issues; economic concerns centred on the resources required to cope with the influx; and political concerns, inasmuch as refugees are seen as rebels against the incumbent socio-political order of the origin state and the act of accommodating them tacit aggression against their state of origin; and also insofar as control over borders and entry is understood as a primary metric of state sovereignty. In the realpolitik realm, a state’s reaction to refugees may often be dictated by domestic prejudice against an ‘Other-ized’ identity – anti-Semitism is understood as a crucial factor in the sealing of many European borders during the 1930s and 40s.
Nations across Europe used a variety of strategies to dissuade Jewish refugees during the Second World War. Switzerland, for example, sealed its borders in August 1942 to block inflow of Jewish refugees, despite reports in the Swiss media from the period showing that the existence of extermination camps in Nazi-occupied Europe was general knowledge. In this wave of anti-refugee sentiment, ‘over-foreignization’ or ‘Überfremdung’ was a recurring term, some conservative campaigns rallied for all refugees to be denied higher schooling. The Americas did not necessarily fare much better – in one particularly notorious case, the S.S. St. Louis, a ship carrying over 930 Jewish refugees, was forced to go back to Europe after Cuba, the US, and several Latin American nations denied them entry.
Shortly after the start of the Second World War, 32 states met in Evian, France to discuss the growing exodus of refugees from Germany and Austria – deliberations that led to the formation of the Intergovernmental Committee on Refugees or ‘IGCR’. An attempt at a more universal asylum mechanism to succeed region-specific schemes, like the Nansen Passports issued to refugees fleeing the Russian civil war. The IGCR remained a toothless body, as participants were concerned more with preventing any further agreement vis-à-vis German refugees seeking asylum, to pacify domestic political opinions. This was reiterated in Marrus’s argument that Evian merely ‘highlighted the unwillingness of most Western states to accommodate Jewish refugees’.
By the end of 1943, more than 15 million people throughout Europe had fled the advancing German armies, 8 million Europeans had been deported to Germany as forced labourers, while 6 million Jews had been moved to Nazi concentration camps in German-occupied Poland. While there was a significant number of survivors among the first two, an overwhelming majority of the third category perished. From all perspectives, mortality figures for Europe’s Jewish citizenry were significantly exacerbated by borderline xenophobic refugee policies.
The post-World War 2 refugee protection regime came as a direct response to this humanitarian catastrophe. There was, therefore, a strong ideological basis for codification of the normative obligation of all states to not return refugees to areas where their life may be at risk. The status of non-refoulement as central to the very purpose of the 1951 Convention may be understood from the fact that it is one of only two articles in the instrument that no contracting state may make a reservation to, the other pertains to the right of ‘exit’ from a state where persecution is inescapable.
2. A crisis of legitimacy
A major practical issue has since developed regarding implementation of non-refoulement – does the rule cover situations of physical blockades of national borders and other measures aimed at preventing any actual entry of asylum seekers? This flows from a major discrepancy in the international refugee rights regime; while the right to seek asylum is recognized, there is no corresponding obligation for a state to grant asylum. Similarly, the right to leave one’s country of origin or habitual residence cannot be operationalized without an obligation on the part of other nation states to grant entry.
Non-refoulement has been explicitly linked to non-rejection at the border in the OAU Convention and the Cartagena Declaration. The UNHCR has repeatedly stressed that “the fundamental principle of non-refoulement involving non-rejection at the frontier must be scrupulously observed.” Actual state practice, however, has obfuscated this. Powerful states in the post-Cold War period maintain that they are under no obligation to allow refugees in, the US Supreme Court consolidated this stance in Sale v. Haitian Councils Centre, 1993, confirming the legality of the US practice of intercepting and forcibly returning Haitians at sea. In other cases, humanitarian rescue agendas have been dictated by interested, powerful Western parties, while the UNHCR plays only a passive role.
In the broader context of rejection at the frontier, physical border closures are a Global South phenomenon, as richer nations typically have far more elaborate methods of keeping refugees out. Strategies have remained largely constant before and after the Second World War, redoubling visa restrictions, narrowing the definition of ‘political refugee’ to exclude certain groups, devising elaborate procedural requirements for asylum applications to create a larger sample space for grounds of rejection, and rejection at sea. Border closures typically have one of two characters – a security/capacity based closure, where a state claims threats to its ‘security’ – economic, demographic or political – to justify rejection. Or participation-based closures – where an otherwise generous host state may seal borders due to a sense of lack of cooperation by the international community.
In one instance – significant in terms of its policy implications – Turkey refused to admit ethnic Kurds fleeing violent state reprisals – including mass-murder of entire Kurdish villages using chemical warfare – for ‘revolutionary activities’ in Saddam-ruled Iraq in the early 90s. Ostensibly a political rather than economic, ‘capacity’ based decision, as over 350,000 Bulgarian Turks were readily accommodated for permanent settlement during The Great Excursion in 1989.
Because of strategic interests along the restive Turkey-Iraq border and in Turkey as a crucial middle-east ally, the US along with other Coalition states lobbied strongly against condemnation of Ankara’s decision to refoule refugees from its border areas. US President Bush argued instead for the establishment of a militarized ‘safe zone’ within Iraqi territory – repatriation contingent upon protection from the Iraqi government, and on continued US military presence (‘Operation Provide Comfort’). Demilitarization would have led to another massive displacement, which Ankara clarified would be met with another border closure – justified by precedent. UNHCR, while initially reluctant to join the repatriation program, eventually shifted its focus away from the Turkish border closure’s impact on asylum.
The key policy implication for UNHCR was that it had little ability to impact events once borders were sealed. In Turkey, it had to face the choice of continuing to resist the politically tainted plans of key donor states (incidentally also the key military powers) which subverted the mandate principles, or actively participate in it – acknowledging its significant impact on protection principles. Political interests and prejudice have continued to underlie international responses to border closures; and states have cited the North Iraq ‘safe zone’ solution, and the US practice of refouling Haitians at sea as justification for blocking refugee inflow.
3. A crisis of hindsight
The refugee law debate has been rekindled in light of the current situation in Europe. Predictably, border control and fencing has come up almost overnight in many host states, ending two decades of open movement in much of the continent. The number of refugees heading for Europe remains minor in absolute terms, none of the top ten host states for inflow are in Europe. Large-scale refugee crises and situations of mass-influx remain a largely Global South phenomenon. As such, given the broader trend of Western practices being taken as precedent, it is important for the UNHCR to articulate a determined stance on current border closures as well as indirect strategies for rejection in Europe. A laissez-faire position on Europe will almost certainly impact its legitimacy should it aim to influence national policies on similar situations in Southern states, which are usually much more severe.
Wesley Hofeld describes four sets of ‘jural correlatives’, legal interests that exist on opposite sides of two entities involved in a legal relationship. A ‘right’ cannot be operationalized without a commensurate ‘duty’ on the part of a state. In these terms alone, non-refoulement remains a chimera at the international level – a full circle since the humanitarian crisis of the Second World War. A puzzling case of global amnesia.
This is nicely put! !
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
online canadian pharcharmy
north west pharmacy canada
Nicely put, Thanks a lot!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
prescription online canadian pharmacies-24h canada pharmacy canadian pharmacies that ship to us
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
overseas pharmacy forum
safe canadian online pharmacies
canadian pharmacy king
us pharmacy no prior prescription
buying drugs canada
Thanks. Plenty of content!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
drugs for sale canadian pharmacies-24h best online pharmacy stores canadian pharmacies
canadian pharmacy reviews
northwestpharmacy
online pharmacies
no prescription pharmacies
rx pharmacy
online pharmacies canada
Thank you. Loads of posts!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
costco pharmacy pricing canadian online pharmacies online prescription drugs canada pharmacy online
canadian prescriptions
walgreens pharmacy
medication costs
canadian pharmacies
canadian drugstore reviews
pharmacy cost comparison
This is nicely expressed! !
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
drug prices comparison canadian pharmacies online online pharmacy reviews canada pharmacy
canada pharmacy online reviews
walgreens pharmacy
canada online pharmacy
canada pharmacy online
overseas pharmacy forum
canada online pharmacies
With thanks, Numerous data!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
northwestpharmacy canada online pharmacies my canadian pharmacy trust pharmacy canada
buy prescription drugs canada
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
buy drugs online
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
candrugstore com
visit poster’s website
Very good tips. Thanks a lot.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
drugs without prescription canadian pharmacy online canadian drugstore canadian pharmacies online
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
prescription cost
the canadian pharmacy
canadian online pharmacy
no prescription pharmacies
best online international pharmacies
Thanks. An abundance of posts.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
discount pharmacy canada pharmacy online 24 hour pharmacy canada pharmacy
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
canadian drugstore
board of pharmacy
drug prices comparison
canada drugs
pharmacy online
Truly many of useful facts!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
rx pharmacy canadian viagra prescription pricing northwest pharmacy
pain meds online without doctor prescription
canadian drugstore online
buy drugs online
online pharmacy
pharmacy canada
canadian pharmacy reviews
Amazing a good deal of very good material!
https://nicktambone.com/
cheap drugs online northwestpharmacy reputable canadian mail order pharmacies canadian drugs
walgreens pharmacy
canada pharmacy no prescription
mexican pharmacy online medications
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
canadian drugstore reviews
most reliable canadian pharmacies
Reliable facts. With thanks.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
pharmacy online store canada pharmaceuticals online mexican online pharmacies canada pharmacy online
mexican pharmacy online medications
pharmacy online
no prescription pharmacies
compare rx prices
cheap drugs online
canadapharmacyonline.com
With thanks. Loads of knowledge!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
northwest pharmacy canadian pharcharmy pharmacy prices compare canadian pharmacies-24h
canada pharmacy online orders
online drugstore
my canadian pharmacy
online pharmacy no prescription
internet pharmacy
online pharmacies
Nicely put, With thanks!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canadian pharma companies canadian pharmacy prescription prices comparison canadian pharmacies online
no prescription online pharmacy
canadadrugs.com pharmacy
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
pharmacy near me
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
buy online prescription drugs
Well spoken of course. !
https://nicktambone.com/
candrugstore com northwestpharmacy pharmacy online northwestpharmacy
canadian pharmacy 365
drugs from canada
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
prescription drug assistance
online canadian pharcharmy
buying prescription drugs canada
Helpful information. Appreciate it!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
canada drugs online pharmacy canadian viagra canadian meds canada pharmaceutical online ordering
online canadian discount pharmacy
prescription pricing
canadian mail order pharmacies
discount pharmacy online
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
canadian pharmacies online
Very well voiced genuinely! .
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canada pharmacy no prescription canadian drugs 24 hour pharmacy online pharmacies of canada
online discount pharmacy
canadian prescription drugstore
compare rx prices
approved canadian pharmacies online
drugs without prescription
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
Kudos, Lots of advice!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
online pharmacies no prescription canadian pharmaceuticals online no prescription pharmacies london drugs canada
cheap canadian drugs
drug costs
drug costs
canada pharmacy online reviews
canadian meds
ed meds online
Cheers! I enjoy it!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadian rx canadianpharmacy drug stores near me canadian pharmacies
discount prescription drug
online drugstore
online drugs
pharmacy price compare
canada pharmacy online
top rated canadian pharmacies online
You reported this well!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canadian online pharmacy global pharmacy canada international pharmacy global pharmacy canada
canadapharmacyonline com
cheap prescription drugs
pharmacy online mexico
board of pharmacy
online rx pharmacy
canadian rx
Cheers! I enjoy it!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canadian drugstore online global pharmacy canada canadian pharmacy online canada northwest pharmacy
walmart pharmacy price check
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
candrugstore com
canadian pharmacies online
online drugs
overseas pharmacy forum
You stated that effectively.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
prescription drugs without prior prescription canada drug rx price comparison canadian viagra
canadian drug stores online
prescription drug cost
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
trusted overseas pharmacies
cheap prescription drugs
canadapharmacyonline.com
Wonderful stuff, Cheers!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
medication costs canada drugs online canada drug prices canadian pharmacies-24h
canadian pharmacies top best
king pharmacy
discount prescription drugs online
buy prescription drugs from canada
prescription drug assistance
canada drug prices
Thanks, Ample posts.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
prescription cost comparison london drugs canada pharmacy online canadian pharmacies that ship to us
online pharmacy usa
canadian drugstore
international pharmacy
top rated online canadian pharmacies
buy drugs online
online drugstore
Awesome information. Thank you.
http://talahicc.com/
international pharmacies that ship to the usa canada pharmaceuticals online web medical information canada drug
canada online pharmacies
pharmacy without dr prescriptions
prescription price comparison
buy cialis
online pharmacy canada
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
Really all kinds of beneficial knowledge.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
online pharmacy without a prescription canada drug canada pharmacy no prescription canada drugs
canadadrugs
buying prescription drugs canada
pharmacy online mexico
best online pharmacy stores
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
web medical information
Very good content, Many thanks!
https://nicktambone.com/
prescription online canadian pharmacies without an rx canadian pharmacy king canadian pharmacies-24h
get prescription online
canada online pharmacy
pharmacy online store
online canadian pharcharmy
most reliable canadian pharmacies
rx pharmacy
You have made your position extremely effectively.!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canadian pharmacy king canadianpharmacy safe canadian online pharmacies trust pharmacy canada
meds online
the canadian pharmacy
discount pharmacy
prescription drugs online without doctor
pharmacy prescription
best non prescription online pharmacies
You actually expressed this wonderfully.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
canadian pharmacy no prescription mexican pharmacies shipping to usa compare rx prices canadian pharmacies
best online pharmacy stores
canadian discount pharmacy
prescription cost
pharmacies in canada
safe canadian online pharmacies
online canadian pharmacy
You definitely made the point.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
online pharmacy without a prescription canadian pharmaceuticals online canada pharmacy online northwest pharmacy
buy cialis
canadian pharmacy viagra brand
canadian family pharmacy
canadian online pharmacy reviews
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
pharmacy online mexico
With thanks! I enjoy it!
https://nicktambone.com/
prescription pricing canada drugs online best price prescription drugs canada drugs
canadian pharmacies online prescriptions
best canadian pharmacies
online pharmacies
pharmacy online mexico
canadapharmacyonline.com
onlinecanadianpharmacy.com
Thank you, A good amount of material!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
pharmacies near me canadianpharmacy canada drug pharmacy global pharmacy canada
online drugs
northwestpharmacy
canadian drugs without prescription
online canadian discount pharmacy
prescription drugs canada
rx online
Fantastic material, Many thanks!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
safe canadian online pharmacies canada drug canadian pharmacies canada pharmacy
ed meds online
online prescription drugs
overseas pharmacy forum
internet pharmacy
mail order pharmacies
pharmacy drug store
You stated that wonderfully!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
my canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacies pharmacy drug store canadian pharmacies-24h
buy prescription drugs canada
the canadian pharmacy
canadian pharma companies
best online pharmacy
legitimate online pharmacies
canadianpharmacy
Whoa tons of fantastic data!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canada pharmacies prescription drugs canadian pharmacy online best online pharmacy canadian pharcharmy
canada pharmacy online reviews
prescription drug price comparison
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
northwest pharmacy canada
drug prices comparison
cheap canadian drugs