On 27th January 2016, Pre-Trial Chamber 1 of the International Criminal Court (ICC) approved the Prosecutor’s application to investigate crimes within Georgia. Under Article 15 of the Rome Statute, when the Prosecutor initiates an investigation proprio motu (that is, of their own accord without UN Security Council or state referral), she must seek the approval of the Pre-Trial Chamber of the Court. Prosecutor Bensouda sought permission to investigate alleged crimes committed between 1st July – 10th October 2008 in South Ossetia, Georgia. Despite the Majority approving the investigation, there were interesting divergences between Judges Aluoch and Tarfusser (who issued a joint judgment with Judge Kovacs) and Judge Kovacs who despite agreeing on the substantive decision of the Court, handed down a separate opinion interpreting the Court’s obligations under Article 15. In this short paper, I will explain the Court’s approach to its role under Article 15.
The International Criminal Court has jurisdiction to hear cases are commenced by the Prosecutor proprio motu. This means that the Prosecutor can commence an investigation of her own accord with the approval of the Court (Art 15). This is a more unusual way for the Court to attract jurisdiction with most cases coming from state or United Nations Security Council referrals. The Prosecutor is responsible for gathering evidence to present an application to the Pre-Trial Chamber for authorisation. Art 15(4) deals with the role of the Court in determining these matters, and states:
If the Pre-Trial Chamber, upon examination of the request and the supporting material, considers that there is a reasonable basis to proceed with an investigation, and that the case appears to fall within the jurisdiction of the Court, it shall authorize the commencement of the investigation, without prejudice to subsequent determinations by the Court with regard to the jurisdiction and admissibility of a case.
Prosecutor Bensouda made an application for authorisation from the Pre-Trial Chamber of an investigation into alleged crimes committed in Georgia under Article 15. She alleged that the war crimes of wilful killing or murder; destruction of property; pillage and intentional attacks on peacekeepers had been committed. Additionally she alleged the crimes against humanity of murder, deportation or forcible transfer of population and persecution. The crimes were alleged against Georgian, Russian and South Ossetian forces and military units. The majority judgment outlines the individual circumstances of each of these alleged offences.
In considering the application, the Majority noted that the test was whether there ‘exists a sensible or reasonable justification for a belief that a crime falling within the jurisdiction of the Court has or is being committed’ [25]. In making their assessment they concluded that there was an international armed conflict between Georgia and Russia, with the South Ossetian forces being controlled by Russia which makes them (Russia) a party to the conflict [27]. In doing so, the Majority felt that the Prosecutor had proven a reasonable justification for a belief that a crime falling within the jurisdiction of the Court had been committed.
The Majority then proceeded to make preliminary assessments against each of the elements of the offences alleged. In relation to assessing admissibility, the Chamber concluded that their determination rests on the ‘information available at this stage and in light of the Prosecutor’s submissions’. The two components of admissibility before the ICC are complementarity and gravity (Art 17). The Majority, invoking Art 53(1)(b) noted that ‘[i]f (some of) those potential cases are not investigated or prosecuted by national authorities’ then complementarity is satisfied. The Majority found that no proceedings within South Ossetia would be considered valid before the ICC, as it is not a recognised state [40]. The Georgian investigation had ceased operation due to a lack of ability to properly investigate in the location of the alleged offences [41]. Finally regarding the Russian investigation a letter was presented which simultaneously suggests that Russian authorities were gathering further evidence and exculpated the command of the Russian military [44]. The Majority found that the complementarity requirement had been satisfied in relation to Georgia and South Ossetia. However, it found itself ‘unable’ to determine whether the Russian proceedings were inadequate due to an insufficiency of evidence [46]. The Majority also suggested that there was no onus on them to seek further evidence in order to resolve this matter.
The Majority also quite quickly dispensed with the matter of gravity. It cited statistics inter alia that 13,400-18,500 persons were displaced and there was a 75% decrease in the ethnically Georgian population in South Ossetia. Finally, the Majority determined that there were no interests of justice which would inhibit such an investigation into the alleged crimes in Georgia. It thus authorised the investigation into events related to the conflict in and around South Ossetia between 1 July and 10 October 2008.
While not disagreeing with the substantive findings of the Majority that the investigation should in principle have been authorised, Judge Kovacs strongly disagreed with their approach to determining the Prosecutor’s application. Judge Kovacs took strong issue with the Majority’s statement that their role was ‘strictly limited’ (Majority judgment [3]). Judge Kovacs conversely emphasises that the Court has a ‘duty to reach its own conclusion’ [5]. He invokes rule 50(4) of the Rules of Procedure and Evidence to suggest that the Court’s power to request further information from the Prosecutor does not accord well with the majority’s view of the Court’s power being strictly limited. Judge Kovacs emphasised that authorisation of a proprio motu investigation requires an ‘independent judicial inquiry’ from the Court [6].
Kovacs also invoked the history of a proprio motu investigation to demonstrate the importance of the Court independently assessing the Prosecutor’s case. He noted the hesitancy of the initial drafters of the Rome Statute to include Art 15 [9]. He emphasised that ‘an agreement would have never been reached in Rome on article 15…without having judicial control before the initiation of an investigation (emphasis in original)’ [10]. After outlining his criticisms, Judge Kovacs then proceeded to outline all of the evidence that he believed should have been considered in the Majority decision, but was not.
One of the main areas that Judge Kovacs considered deficient in the Majority decision, was the failure to establish a crucial component of the crime of attacking peacekeepers. In his view, the Majority did not even establish that the peacekeepers were those who can properly receive protection under the Rome Statute [18]. Judge Kovacs’ variance with the Majority becomes clear as he implored that the Court should go beyond the submissions of the Prosecutor and request further information as, and when, required [20].
On issues of admissibility Judge Kovacs echoed his previous concerns. He claimed that the Majority withheld important facts from their written decision which would have strengthened the persuasiveness and logic of their decision [41]. On his reading of the evidence, it was clear that there was a lack of willingness on the part of Georgia to prosecute the crimes. One of the documents that the Prosecutor relied upon was an unsigned decree of charges [48]. He asserted that the Chamber should have requested further evidence from the Prosecutor to properly make their decision.
Despite the differences of opinion, the Pre-Trial Chamber of the International Criminal Court authorised the Prosecutorial investigation into Georgia. This is an important step in the process of justice for the people living within that region. Important lessons can be drawn from this decision into what the Prosecutor is required to present to the Court in an Article 15 application for authorisation of an investigation. Whilst the Majority were satisfied with the evidence presented before them by the Prosecutor, Judge Kovacs was not, and went to great lengths to describe what further information he would have requested and the way that he sees the role of the Court under an Article 15 application.
Kudos, I like it!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
mexican online pharmacies
aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
canada pharmacy online orders
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
Seriously plenty of great facts!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
prescription drugs online without doctor canadian pharcharmy canadian pharmacy without prescription canadian online pharmacies
buy cialis
canadapharmacy com
get prescription online
mail order pharmacy
rx pharmacy
canadian pharmacy online
Superb write ups. Kudos!
http://talahicc.com/
online pharmacies canada north west pharmacy canada online pharmacies canadian viagra
discount drugs online pharmacy
my canadian pharmacy
canadian drug stores online
online rx pharmacy
prescription drug
online pharmacies canada
You stated it adequately!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
safeway pharmacy canada pharmaceutical online ordering canada pharmacy online no script canadian online pharmacy
prescription drugs without doctor approval
canada pharmacies without script
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
online pharmacy without a prescription
canadian mail order pharmacies
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
You said it adequately.!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
discount prescription drug canadian online pharmacies board of pharmacy canadian pharmacy
online pharmacy reviews
buy drugs online
northwestpharmacy
canada pharmacy
best canadian online pharmacy
prescription drugs online without
Thanks! I value this.
http://talahicc.com/
canada pharmacies online prescriptions london drugs canada northwestpharmacy canadian pharmacies
canada pharmacies
online pharmacy usa
prescription drug assistance
canadian pharmacy king
cialis canadian pharmacy
canadian drugstore online
Regards! Very good information!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
rx pharmacy canadian pharmacy online buy prescription drugs without doctor canadian pharmacies-24h
canada pharmacies online prescriptions
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
prescription drugs online without
canadian pharmacy online
legitimate online pharmacies
candrugstore com
Whoa a good deal of helpful info!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canadian prescription northwest pharmacy online pharmacy without prescription global pharmacy canada
canadian cialis
safeway pharmacy
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
visit poster’s website
top rated online canadian pharmacies
pharmacy near me
Nicely put, Kudos.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canada pharmacy online no script canada pharmacy medical information online canadianpharmacy
best canadian mail order pharmacies
canadian pharmacy without prescription
approved canadian pharmacies online
cheap drugs online
prescription drug assistance
mail order pharmacy
Nicely put, Thanks!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
pharmacy online store canada drugs compare rx prices london drugs canada
canadian viagra
cheap prescription drugs online
canadian drug store
drug price
prescription online
prescription prices comparison
Regards! I value it.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canadian online pharmacy reviews canada pharmaceuticals online canadian pharmacy without prescription canada online pharmacies
canada pharmacies without script
online canadian pharmacy
canadian online pharmacy
canada meds
canada pharmacies online
pharmacy tech
Thanks a lot! Numerous information!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canadian prescriptions canadian pharmacy buy prescription drugs online canadian cialis
canadian online pharmacies
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
drugs online
canadian drugstore
24 hour pharmacy
most reliable canadian pharmacies
Incredible tons of valuable knowledge.
http://talahicc.com/
drugstore online canadian pharmacies that ship to us ed meds online global pharmacy canada
drug prices comparison
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
discount pharmacy online
pharmacy online store
ed meds online
canada pharmacies online
You’ve made the point!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
prescription cost comparison canada drugs online canadian rx canada drugs online
meds online
pharmacy prices compare
best online pharmacies no prescription
online pharmacy no prescription needed
cheap drugs online
canadian pharcharmy online
You’ve made your stand quite clearly.!
http://talahicc.com/
prescription pricing mexican pharmacies shipping to usa international pharmacies that ship to the usa northwest pharmacy
prescription drugs prices
pharmacy prices compare
best online international pharmacies
canadadrugs
canadianpharmacy
pharmacy online mexico
Nicely put, Cheers!
https://nicktambone.com/
canada drug trust pharmacy canada mail order pharmacy canada drug
northwestpharmacy
pharmacy online store
pharmacy online
buy online prescription drugs
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
prescription drugs canada
You have made your point.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
discount pharmacy online online pharmacies canada canadian pharmacy mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
pharmacy drug store
canadian pharmacies that are legit
no prescription pharmacies
meds online
trusted overseas pharmacies
canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
Nicely put, Thanks a lot.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
pharmacy online mexico northwestpharmacy canadian pharmacies canadian pharmacy online
canadian online pharmacy
canadian prescriptions
canadian mail order pharmacies
cheap canadian drugs
get prescription online
mexican pharmacies online
Wow many of excellent information!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
prescription price comparison online pharmacies of canada mexican pharmacy online medications canadianpharmacy
trust pharmacy canada
online canadian pharmacies
no prior prescription required pharmacy
canadian pharmacies online
pharmacy online
prescription drugs online without doctor
You said it nicely..
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canadian pharma companies online pharmacies of canada overseas pharmacy forum online pharmacies canada
drugs without prescription
canadian pharmacy online canada
canada pharmacies online pharmacy
canada pharmacy
northwest pharmacy canada
canada meds
Fantastic data. Thanks a lot!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
online canadian pharcharmy canadian pharmacies without an rx rx online canadian pharmacies without an rx
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
canadian cialis
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
online rx pharmacy
best canadian online pharmacy
discount pharmaceuticals
Kudos. Loads of data!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
discount pharmacy canadian pharmacies no prescription pharmacies canadian pharmacies without an rx
best online pharmacy stores
ed meds online
compare prescription prices
canada online pharmacies
online canadian pharmacy
mexican pharmacy online
You actually stated this well.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
medical information online canadian pharmacy online mexican online pharmacies canada pharmacy
price prescription drugs
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
online pharmacies no prescription
safe canadian online pharmacies
walgreens pharmacy
canadian drugstore online
Kudos, Fantastic information.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
top rated canadian pharmacies online canadian pharmacies online best price prescription drugs northwestpharmacy
24 hour pharmacy
the canadian pharmacy
canadian prescription
pharmacy prescription
mexican online pharmacies
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
Terrific postings, With thanks.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
prescription drug assistance canadian pharmacy mail order pharmacies top rated canadian pharmacies online
canadian drugs without prescription
canada meds
buy prescription drugs from canada
online pharmacy reviews
online canadian pharcharmy
onlinecanadianpharmacy.com
You said it nicely..
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canadian pharmacies canada drugs highest rated canadian pharmacies canadian pharmaceuticals online
pharmacy without dr prescriptions
best canadian online pharmacy
canada pharmacy online
canadian drug stores online
drug costs
pharmacy prices
You stated it very well!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
buy prescription drugs without doctor canadian online pharmacy canada pharmacies northwest pharmacy
canada drugs pharmacy
prescription price comparison
drug prices comparison
discount prescription drugs online
prescription online
medication costs
Helpful stuff. Appreciate it!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
prescription drugs without doctor approval canadian online pharmacy mexican pharmacies canada drug
drug stores near me
canadian pharmacies
no prior prescription required pharmacy
canada meds
canada drug prices
canadian pharmacies
Information very well considered!!
https://nicktambone.com/
pharmacy cost comparison canadian pharmacies online canadian online pharmacy reviews canadian cialis
canada drug prices
canada pharmacies online prescriptions
northwestpharmacy
canada online pharmacies
canadian pharmacies that are legit
online canadian pharmacies
Wow all kinds of great facts.
http://talahicc.com/
online pharmacy without a prescription canada drugs the canadian pharmacy canadian viagra
canadian prescriptions
canadian pharmacies top best
best online pharmacies canada
canadian pharmacy without prescription
pharmacy online
buy prescription drugs canada
You actually mentioned it exceptionally well!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
mail order pharmacies canada online pharmacies canadian prescriptions northwest pharmacy
canadianpharmacy
canada pharmacies
canadadrugs.com pharmacy
pharmacies in canada
rx price comparison
approved canadian pharmacies online
Kudos! Very good information!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online london drugs canada cheap prescription drugs canadianpharmacy
pharmacy online store
prescription drugs without prior prescription
buy prescription drugs from canada
canadapharmacy com
best online canadian pharcharmy
buy online prescription drugs
You said this terrifically.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
online pharmacies no prescription canadian pharmacy online canada online pharmacy canadian pharmacy
king pharmacy
northwest pharmacy
cheap prescription drugs online
prescription drugs online without doctor
canadapharmacy
price prescription drugs
Nicely put, Thanks a lot!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa aarp approved canadian online pharmacies online discount pharmacy aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
online canadian pharcharmy
legitimate online pharmacies
drugs without prescription
no prior prescription required pharmacy
cheap canadian drugs
prescription drugs canada
Nicely put, Many thanks.
http://talahicc.com/
canadian prescription aarp approved canadian online pharmacies canadian rx pharmacy online canadian online pharmacy
canadian pharmacies that are legit
canadian family pharmacy
online pharmacy no prescription needed
online canadian pharmacies
prescription drugs without prior prescription
canada drugs online
Seriously many of superb material.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
pharmacies in canada canadian pharmacies that ship to us rx online canadian pharmacies without an rx
canadapharmacy com
canada online pharmacy
pharmacy prices
prescription online
mexican pharmacy online
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
Kudos! Fantastic stuff.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canadian prescription drugstore canadian pharmacies-24h overseas pharmacy forum canadian pharmacies that ship to us
mexican pharmacy online medications
canadian drugs
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
canada online pharmacy
pharmacy cost comparison
best canadian prescription prices
Many thanks! I like this!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
drug stores near me london drugs canada canadian pharmacies top best aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
best online pharmacies canada
mexican pharmacies
canadian prescription drugstore
no prescription pharmacies
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
best canadian pharmacies
Nicely put, With thanks.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
canada online pharmacy canadian online pharmacies prescription online trust pharmacy canada
walmart pharmacy price check
canadapharmacy com
online canadian pharmacy
drugs without prescription
cheap canadian drugs
international pharmacies that ship to the usa
Wonderful tips. Thank you!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canada pharmacies without script canadian pharmacy online online pharmacies no prescription trust pharmacy canada
trusted overseas pharmacies
the canadian pharmacy
best canadian pharmacies
canadian prescription drugs
canadapharmacy com
cheap prescription drugs online
Amazing information. Regards!
https://nicktambone.com/
us pharmacy no prior prescription trust pharmacy canada pharmacy cost comparison canada pharmacy
pharmacy near me
pharmacies in canada
meds online
medication costs
internet pharmacy
canada drugs online pharmacy
Appreciate it! Plenty of stuff.
https://nicktambone.com/
canadian rx pharmacy online canada drugs online canadian prescription trust pharmacy canada
canadian drugstore
canadian drugstore online
meds online
canadian pharmacy 365
online drugs
canadian rx pharmacy online
Incredible many of great information!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
mexican pharmacies online canada online pharmacies canada pharmacy no prescription northwestpharmacy
international pharmacies that ship to the usa
meds online
ed meds online
canadian drugstore reviews
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
best canadian pharmacies
Well expressed truly! !
https://nicktambone.com/
rx pharmacy northwest pharmacy pharmacy price compare mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
mexican online pharmacies
online drugs
cheap canadian drugs
safe canadian online pharmacies
buy cialis
canada pharmacy online orders
Whoa lots of valuable facts!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa canadian pharmacies drugs without prescription northwest pharmacy
canada drug pharmacy
prescription drug
cheap prescription drugs online
canada pharmacy online reviews
compare prescription prices
trust pharmacy canada
Kudos, Numerous content!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
buy cialis canadian pharmacies without an rx top rated online canadian pharmacies canada pharmacy online
drug costs
pharmacy canada
cheap canadian drugs
buy drugs online
drug prices comparison
online pharmacy
Good stuff. Many thanks.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canada drugs pharmacy canadian online pharmacy cialis online canada online pharmacies
discount pharmacy online
canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
buy online prescription drugs
canada pharmacies without script
canadian pharmacy without prescription
mexican pharmacies